
Dogs will be dogs, but try telling that to the longtime married couple whose gay next-door neighbors’ pet pooch does the unthinkable to their beloved bunny rabbit in Michelle Kholos Brooks’ Nacho Ate Spiderman, now making a serious point or two amongst loads of laughs in its West Coast Premiere at the Ruskin Group Theatre.
To confess, or not to confess. That’s the dilemma facing Brad (Jamie Pierce) and Brad (Matthew Scott Montgomery) when the same-sex twosome discover a mangled furry corpse on their front lawn and immediately recognize it as the “free-range” rabbit their neighbors Devorah and Xander (Sharon Lawrence and Dann Florek) consider their “child,” and realize in an instant that their beloved Spiderman, “the baby” they rescued from the mean streets of Tijuana, must be the killer.
Not that big-hearted vegetarian Spidey meant to commit murder.
It was simply a case of overexcitement, of impulsivity, of being in the wrong place at the wrong time, and seriously, what pet parents in their right mind would let a prize-winning purebred rabbit hop around the neighborhood, even one where cars are permitted only in the alleys behind the beach-adjacent community’s pedestrians-only country-style lanes?
And it’s not like the Brads are bad people, not when you consider how many donations they made to the good candidates during the election, not when you add up how many good clothes they give to homeless shelters, to World Kitchen, and to PETA for goodness sake!
So, really, what are a generous, well-intentioned couple like Brad and Brad to do but bury poor Spiderman amidst the posies blooming in their front yard and hope that Devorah and Xander remain none the wiser.
That, unfortunately, might be more easily said that done once Xander’s wife spots the hole Nacho dug under the fence separating their two properties, and especially not when the Brads get invited next door for an evening of vegan cashew cheese accompanied by smokey Scottish whiskey likely to loosen tongues no matter how much the gay pair may wish not to let anything incriminating slip.
Playwright Brooks makes the amusing most of her characters’ quirks (Devorah is about as new-agey as they get, Xander keeps putting his foot in his well-intentioned mouth, and the Brads can’t stop worrying about the psychological trauma poor Nacho must be going through) while sprinkling in hints that none of these privileged folks may be quite as perfect as they might wish us to believe. (The “radically compassionate” Brads, for example, think nothing about evicting their elderly longtime tenant if it means “improving” the neighborhood.)
All of this adds up to a terrific showcase for Brooks’ talent as a writer. And talk about versatility. Nacho Ate Spiderman couldn’t be more different than her previous Hostage or H*tler’s Tasters.
Not only that, but with director Casey Stangl adeptly navigating potential pitfalls (as when the Nacho Ate Spiderman takes a sudden 11th-hour dramatic turn), Brooks’ latest proves a fabulous comedic showcase for the divine Lawrence, the droll Florek, and the deliciously flamboyant duo that are Pierce and Montgomery’s pair of matching Brads, all four actors displaying razor-sharp timing while fleshing out characters that might at first appear to be well-worn stereotypes.
Nacho Ate Superman looks terrific too with Stephanie Kerley Schwartz giving us two distinctly designed side-by-side homes lit to sunny SoCal perfection by Brandon Baruch, Hannah Owens-Bender’s costumes revealing at first sight just who Brooks’ characters are, Megan Trapani providing a big bunch of props (including a set of Devorah’s priceless inherited glasses and a deceased Spiderman plushy), and sound designer Keith Stevenson adding an expert mix of just-right music and alternately amusing and dramatic effects along the way.
Nacho Ate Spiderman is produced by John Ruskin and Michael Myers. Schwartz is associate producer. Nicole Millar is stage manager and Emma Sanchez is assistant stage manager. Casting is by Victoria Hoffman. Judith Borne is publicist.
It takes a talented playwright to sneak in issues of privilege, liberalism, and gentrification amidst an abundance of laughs, but that’s precisely what Michelle Kholos Brooks has done in Nacho Ate Superman.
Indeed, there may be no better alternative to the traditional holiday fare about to be filling L.A. theaters than this farcical, satirical gem.
Ruskin Group Theatre, 2800 Airport Avenue, Santa Monica. Through December 20. Fridays and Saturdays at 8:00, Sundays at 2:00. No performances on Nov. 14, 19; Dec. 3, 12. Added performances at 8pm on Nov. 16; Dec. 7, 14
www.ruskingrouptheatre.com
–Steven Stanley
November 21, 2026
Photos: Jenny Graham
Tags: Los Angeles Theater Review, Michelle Kholos Brooks, Ruskin Group Theatre

Since 2007, Steven Stanley's StageSceneLA.com has spotlighted the best in Southern California theater via reviews, interviews, and its annual StageSceneLA Scenies.


COPYRIGHT 2026 STEVEN STANLEY :: DESIGN BY